Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Erik Dolson's avatar

You write: "Notice that she is so casual, in writing about rate bias above, that the more vaccinated people there are, the more vaccinated people will die. It should be just the opposite if the vaccines worked!"

No, that's not how the math works. The vaccines are not 100% effective.

Let's say we have a population of 10,000 people, and a deadly pandemic where 20 percent of people who contract the disease die. At first, no one is vaccinated, and if 1000 people catch the disease, 200 of them die.

Then a vaccine is developed. Let's say it's 80% effective at preventing death. If all of the population had had the vaccine initially, only 40 of the original 1000 would have died (20% x 200), reducing the death rate to 4% from 20%.

Then 90 percent of the population is vaccinated. Everyone is exposed to the virus and varients. Of 9,000 vaxxed, 360 die (4% x 9,000). Of the unvaxxed, 200 die (20% x 1,000).

Antivaxxers scream "More vaccinated people are dying than unvaxxed! Vaccines are killing peope!" When in fact, if no one had been vaxxed, 2,000 would have died.

Yes, this is an oversimplification. But not as oversimplified as saying "vaccines don't work because vaccinated people die."

Expand full comment
20 more comments...

No posts